10 Top-Rated WWE 2K23 Superstars

The Best Wrestlers in the Game

Whenever a new WWE 2K game is released, it triggers discussions about the rankings given to wrestlers. Each wrestler is assigned a rating that determines their prowess within the game. However, these ratings aren’t solely based on their real-life skills due to the scripted nature of wrestling matches.

For instance, despite Chad Gable’s exceptional technical abilities, he rarely receives a high rating because of his on-screen losses. However, this isn’t the case for certain wrestlers who have consistently showcased dominance throughout wrestling history, earning them the highest ratings on the WWE 2K23 roster.

10. Brock Lesnar ’14 – 95

One of the matches in John Cena’s showcase mode features a showdown with the 2014 version of Brock Lesnar. This recreation mirrors their memorable SummerSlam encounter in 2014, where the beast dominated the renowned wrestler in a highly one-sided victory.

During that period, Brock’s dominance was unparalleled. He not only defeated the biggest star in the business but also ended Undertaker’s famed WrestleMania streak in the same year. Hence, a high rating was inevitable. Yet, some argue that it could have been even higher.

9. Bianca Belair – 95

Over recent years, Bianca Belair has emerged as a rising star in WWE. With several lengthy title reigns and victories over top-tier wrestlers like Becky Lynch, Bayley, and Sasha Banks, her accomplishments have resulted in improved ratings in the 2K games.

Starting with a rating of 77 in her debut, she now boasts an impressive 95 rating. Being one of the most dominant stars in WWE today, irrespective of gender, justifies this rating. Notably, since WWE 2K22, she has consistently held a title.

8. John Cena ’09 – 95

One of John Cena’s versions in the game hails from 2009. Throughout that year, he was prominently featured in the main event scene, engaging in battles against the likes of Edge, Randy Orton, and Triple H. Despite notable losses, many of these defeats involved various factors, and Cena often emerged triumphant. Additionally, he claimed the World Title multiple times, solidifying his strong year. Therefore, the 95 rating is well-deserved.

7. The Undertaker – 95

While some wrestlers only appeared in a single WWE game, The Undertaker has been a consistent presence in the series for numerous years. Even after his retirement, he continues to be included in every installment. Notably, he consistently receives an impressive rating.

However, even by his standards, the 95 rating is notably high. It reflects his legendary career in WWE, earning him this remarkable rating.

6. John Cena ’12 And John Cena ’14 – 96

The highest-rated regular versions of John Cena in the game originate from 2012 and 2014. Considering Cena’s comparable status during these years, it’s unsurprising that 2K didn’t differentiate their ratings.

This period marked his “SuperCena” phase, where he consistently dominated the top of the card, triumphing over nearly every opponent. Losses were either surprising or involved outside interference. Hence, the 96 rating appropriately represents Cena during this era.

5. The Rock – 96

The Rock’s infrequent appearances on WWE screens, owing to his busy movie career, always generate significant buzz. His significance, however, extends beyond his roles in Black Adam and the Fast And Furious franchise; he remains one of the greatest wrestlers and entertainers in wrestling history.

As a legend in every game, he consistently receives high ratings. In WWE 2K23, he achieves a score of 96, marking a three-point increase from his rating in 2K22.

4. “Stone Cold” Steve Austin – 96

“Stone Cold” Steve Austin is another legendary figure present in every installment of the series. Despite not actively competing, he headlined WrestleMania’s first night in 2022 against Kevin Owens, displaying commendable performance despite the years since his last match.

His 96 rating likely stems from his portrayal during his peak as the company’s biggest star in the late ’90s, where he dominated the competition. Therefore, the 96 rating is a reflection of his legendary status.

3. Becky Lynch – 96

Since discarding her steampunk persona in 2018, Becky Lynch has ascended to become one of the industry’s top talents. Arguably WWE’s most significant female star, she has participated in numerous high-profile matches and claimed multiple championships.

Maintaining her popularity since WWE 2K22, even if she’s taken a slightly less prominent role compared to Bianca Belair, she receives the highest rating ever given to a female superstar in gaming: 96, four points higher than her 2K22 score.

2. Brock Lesnar – 97

Brock Lesnar’s allure lies in his dominant persona, making him virtually unbeatable and a compelling opponent for wrestlers in the game. To replicate this in 2K, he consistently receives a high rating. In WWE 2K23, he attains his highest score yet: 97.

Despite some losses since 2K22, notably to Roman Reigns, his status as a dominant force on the roster justifies this exceptional rating.

1. Roman Reigns – 99

From 2020 to 2K23, Roman Reigns has delivered one of WWE’s most remarkable runs in history. Unified world titles, victories over top-tier opponents like Brock Lesnar, Kevin Owens, and Drew McIntyre, and an unprecedented level of dominance have solidified his reign.

To accurately portray his dominance in the virtual realm, 2K assigns him a record-breaking 99 rating, the highest for a regular wrestler in the series’ history. Only two entities surpass this score, neither of whom are regular competitors – one is made of gold, and the other is invisible. Consequently, beating Roman Reigns in the game is as challenging as it is in real WWE matches.